Dustin May’s 2026 was a season of two halves, and it ended with a World Series title and a big payday. The 29-year-old right-hander has agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the White Sox, an average of $17.5 million a year, after declining a $20 million mutual option with the Brewers. He’s No. 519 in our latest Top 700 Dynasty Rankings, and the move to Chicago gives him a fresh start and a clear path to a rotation spot.
The 2026 season by the numbers
May finished 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA, a 1.32 WHIP and 144 strikeouts in 145⅔ innings. He made a career-high 31 starts, and the innings were a career high too.
The numbers split cleanly between his two teams:
- Cardinals (21 starts): 5-7, 4.38 ERA, 106 strikeouts in 109 innings.
- Brewers (10 starts): 2-2, 5.65 ERA, 38 strikeouts in 36⅔ innings.
St. Louis traded him to Milwaukee for two outfield prospects. The Cardinals had a good first four months with him, including a start in which he carried a no-hit bid deep into a game at Milwaukee, and it was that start that made him a trade target. His results dipped afterward, and he failed to complete five innings in six of seven starts late in the year.
What the underlying numbers say
The 3.63 FIP, almost a full run below his ERA, suggests he was unlucky. His home run to fly ball rate of 9.2% was the lowest of his career in a season with at least 100 innings. Earlier in the year, FanGraphs noted that he’d cut his walk rate to 6.6% from 9.8% in 2025 and lowered his home run rate sharply.
His stuff is strong, but the strikeouts have lagged. His four-seam fastball averaged 96.8 mph, in the 84th percentile, and his sweeper was his best pitch, with a 33% whiff rate and a .267 wOBA against. Even so, his strikeout rate (23.1%) and whiff rate (22.4%) were below the median at the trade deadline. He also had a platoon issue, since left-handed hitters were far more successful against him than right-handers (.353 wOBA to .240) as of early June.
The health history is the biggest risk. He’s had two Tommy John surgeries, missed all of 2024 recovering from the second and an esophageal tear, and dealt with forearm soreness in September 2025. His 145⅔ innings this year show he can hold up, but the White Sox are betting on his health as much as his talent.
His role in the World Series run
May worked in a flexible role in October. He started Game 3 of the NLDS against the Padres, threw three innings behind an opener in the NLCS, tossed a scoreless inning in Game 2 of the World Series, and then started Game 4 against Tampa Bay, allowing two runs in three innings in a bullpen game. He wasn’t a key figure in the run, but he was a useful depth piece on the team that won Milwaukee’s first title.
Dynasty outlook
At No. 519, May is a depth piece for deep leagues, and that ranking looks about right. The White Sox went 84-78 and reached the postseason, finished near the top of the league in offense, and had a rotation that logged the fewest innings in the majors. May will slot in behind Sean Burke, and the combination of run support and a clear rotation job gives him a shot at a solid win total.
The ceiling is modest. A strikeout rate in the low 20s and a history of injuries make him a mid-rotation fantasy starter at best, and some outlets have already called the deal a possible overpay. Still, the FIP and the sweeper suggest the 2026 ERA understated how well he pitched.
Managers in deep or points leagues can use him as a bounce-back streamer with real upside. Everyone else should treat him as a watch-list arm and wait for the early-season results, since his injury history means any rotation spot is only as safe as his elbow.